Doubt and Faith: My Crisis in Faith and Why I am Still a Christian an Advent Meditation

Note to my readers. This is an older article that I wrote back in December 2009, when after nearly two years of struggle with the effects of PTSD, depression, anxiety, loss and a crisis of faith that made me for all practical purposes an agnostic. I think it is timely now, not because of what is currently going on in my life but rather because of the stories I hear from those that struggle with faith at Christmas. Peace, Padre Steve+

Lord I believe, help me in my unbelief.

A new liturgical year is upon us and with the season of Advent Christians look forward to the “Advent” of Christ both in looking forward to the consummation of all things in him as well as inviting him back into our lives as we remember his Incarnation, as the Creed says “For us and for our salvation he came down from heaven: by the power of the Holy Spirit he became incarnate from the Virgin Mary, and was made man.”

At the same time for a lot of people the season of Advent and Christmas are incredibly difficult and times where faith, already difficult becomes nearly impossible.  For many the season is not a time of joy but depression, sadness and despair.

For me Advent and Christmas were times of wonder and mystery and I really found it difficult to understand how anyone could be depressed during the season.  Until I came home from Iraq…

While I believe the Scriptures and the Creed this I have to admit that for the last 22 months since returning from Iraq I have doubted, been depressed and at times felt like God had abandoned me.  Things were so difficult last year that I went to the Christmas Eve Mass with the Abbess and was crashing so hard that I had to leave. I walked through the night for over an hour until I got home, a walk that is a maximum of 10 to 15 minutes from the church.  It was probably the lowest point of my life as a Priest, chaplain and Christian.

Since I returned from Iraq my life has been a series of ups and major downs. In dealing with PTSD, anxiety, depression and chronic insomnia as well as my dad’s painfully slow degeneration with Alzheimer’s disease to the point that he no longer recognized me on my last visit, I have struggled with faith.  Prayer became difficult at best and as I dealt with different things in life I knew that I didn’t have any easy answers.  Going to church was painful. Chaplain conferences even more so, except being with others who struggled like me.  About the only place that I could find solace was at a baseball park.  For some reason the lush green diamond comforts me.

I find that the issue of doubt is not uncommon for a lot of people, including ministers of all faiths. For those of us who are ordained and view our ministry or our Priesthood as a sacred vocation this is difficult to deal with.  Ministers and others who suffer a crisis in faith, depression or despair endure a hell because it is not supposed to happen to us. I do believe that for many people a religious leader who has doubts and struggles with his or her faith is disconcerting.  I can remember a myriad of situations where pastors due to a myriad of reasons experienced a crisis in faith many of which involved great personal loss such as the loss of a child, a failed marriage, being let go or fired by a church, or experiencing a major traumatic event.  These were good people and quite often instead of being enfolded by a caring community of faith they were treated as faithless, failed and worthless, often abandoned or excluded from their faith community as if they were criminals.

When I was younger I used to look askance at pastors who had given up, lost their faith, or abandoned the ministry for whatever reason.  As a young seminary student and later young chaplain I had a hard time with this, it made no sense to me and I was somewhat judgmental until I started to get to know a decent number of “broken” ministers from various faith traditions that a lot more went into their decision than simply not being tough enough to hang in there until things got better.  At the same time I never thought it would happen to me. I thought I was “bulletproof,” that it could never happen to me. And it did and I was stunned.

When I came back from Iraq I came home to find that my office had been packed up and many mementos lost, it took months to find most and there are still important documents that have never been recovered. My accomplishments went unrecognized on my return home.  As I crashed no one asked about my faith until Elmer the shrink did when he met me.  Later my Commodores, first Frank Morneau when he found out about my condition and Bob Sitsch when he took command of EOD Group 2 both asked me about my faith.  I told them that I was struggling. Commodore Sitsch asked me “Where does a Chaplain go for help?”  On the professional side I felt isolated from much of my church and many chaplains.  I was angry because I felt that I deserved better, because I had done all that was asked of me and more.  The Chaplains that I knew cared all worked in different commands and were not immediately available and I was ashamed to go ask them for help.

I appreciated simple questions like “How are you doing with the Big Guy?” or “Where does a Chaplain go to for help?” It showed me that people cared.  When I went to the medical center I dealt with many difficult situations and was haunted by my dad’s deterioration, the latter which I still deal with today.  To have a close family member mock my vocation, service and person and provoke me into rages was equally taxing.  Likewise the absolute hatred and divsion in the American political debate tore my heart out.  I felt like, and in some ways still feel like we are heading down a path to being “Weimar America.”

There were many times that I knew that I had no faith.  People would ask me to pray and it was all that I could do to do to pray and hoped that God would hear me.  Even the things that I found comforting, the Mass, the Liturgy and the Daily Office were painful.

This Christmas and Advent is better than last.  I am finding meaning again.  The little Episcopal Church that I attend helps me in this.  It is much like the churches that I grew up in.  The hymns and the liturgy are comforting.  I am beginning to rediscover faith.  A week and a half ago I was paged stat or our ER where an elderly man was dying.  He was 91 years old and had suffered a heart attack at his family home not far from the hospital.  He has served as a Navy Officer and later Navy doctor and had done his internship at our medical center in the 1940s.

I sprinted to the ER and when I got to his room was introduced to his wife.  She asked if I would pray and then asked if I was Episcopal.  I said I was a Priest in an Episcopal denomination and she asked if I could give her husband, a life-long Episcopalian the last rites.  The man was obviously in his last moments of life.  I performed the Rite and when I finished he passed away.  My hand was on his brow when he breathed his last and his body began to lose its warmth.  One of the Doctors said it was like he had waited until I got there.  The man died with his family, was at home in the house his father built and had eaten what he said was the best “stew of his life” before he passed out.  He died at the hospital he trained at and loved with his family at his side and received the last rites of the Church.  I left the ER after a wonderful chat with his wife, who reflected on his life and how blessed that he was to go out like this.  I left the ER knowing that I had been part of something miraculous.  My eyes were opened and for one of the few times in the past 22 months I felt the presence of God again.

I am still a Christian.  Why is sometimes hard to figure.  I am not a Christian because of the my Church, though I love the Church, it often has been for me a sourse of pain and rejection.  I am not a Christian because of what is called “Christian” nor can I ignore the injustice, violence and oppression wrought by those who called themsleves Christian throughout history.  Slavery, the subjectation and conquest of who peoples to take their land and resources and wars of agression blessed by “Christian” leaders are all part of history.  At the same time much progress has come through the work, faith and actions of Christians and the Church. Despite all of the warts I can like Hans Kung “I can feel fundamentally positive about a tradition that is significant for me; a tradition in which I live side by side with so many others, past and present.” (Kung, Hans Why I am Still a Christian Abingdon Press, Nashville 1987 p. 36)

Neither am I a Christian because I think that the Christian faith has “all” of the answers.  In fact coming through Iraq I understand what my Church History Professor, Dr Doyle Young said “all of people’s deepest needs are not religious.”  Nor am I a Christian because I think that Christians are somehow better or more spiritual than others.  In fact I find the crass materialism and self centered “What can God to for me?” theology and way of life to be deeply offensive.  People get sick, young children die, innocents are subjected to trauma even from their parents or siblings.  Good people endure unspeakable trials while sometimes it seems that evil people get away with murder.  I can’t chealk it all up to a naive “it’s God’s will” kind of theology.  I don’t presume to know God’s will and I can’t be satisfied with pat answers like I see given in so many allegedly Christian publications, sermons and media outlets.  Praying doesn’t always make things better. I remain a Christian in spite of these things.  I still believe that God cares in spite of everything else, in spite of my own doubts, fears and failure.  I still believe, Lord help me in my unbelief.

I look forward to Christmas this year. I look forward to the coming of Emmanuel, God with us.  We sang the hymn “O Come O Come Emmanuel” at Church Sunday.  It was what I needed to hear.

O come, O come, Emmanuel
And ransom captive Israel
That mourns in lonely exile here
Until the Son of God appear
Rejoice! Rejoice! Emmanuel
Shall come to thee, O Israel.

O come, Thou Rod of Jesse, free
Thine own from Satan’s tyranny
From depths of Hell Thy people save
And give them victory o’er the grave
Rejoice! Rejoice! Emmanuel
Shall come to thee, O Israel.

O come, Thou Day-Spring, come and cheer
Our spirits by Thine advent here
Disperse the gloomy clouds of night
And death’s dark shadows put to flight.
Rejoice! Rejoice! Emmanuel
Shall come to thee, O Israel.

O come, Thou Key of David, come,
And open wide our heavenly home;
Make safe the way that leads on high,
And close the path to misery.
Rejoice! Rejoice! Emmanuel
Shall come to thee, O Israel.

O come, O come, Thou Lord of might,
Who to Thy tribes, on Sinai’s height,
In ancient times did’st give the Law,
In cloud, and majesty and awe.
Rejoice! Rejoice! Emmanuel
Shall come to thee, O Israel.

For those that like me struggle with faith, feel abandoned by God, family and friends.  For those who have experienced the crisis of faith or even a loss of faith I pray that all of us will experience joy this season.  I’m sure that I will have some ups and downs, I certainly don’t think that I am over all that I am still going through.  However I know that I am not alone to face my demons and pray that by opening up that others who are going through similar experiences will find hope.  O come, Thou Day-Spring, come and cheer, our spirits by Thine advent here. Disperse the gloomy clouds of night, and death’s dark shadows put to flight.

Peace,

Padre Steve+

Advertisements

17 Comments

Filed under Pastoral Care, PTSD, Religion

17 responses to “Doubt and Faith: My Crisis in Faith and Why I am Still a Christian an Advent Meditation

  1. Thank you for sharing your thoughts and your heart. I admire your strength and faith. Does one really have “faith” if it has never been put to the test? I do not know. However, one who had their faith tested and endures knows, at least a little better, the source of their faith

  2. It’s always seemed so American to me that we assume faith is always forward, always onward and upward.

    Life is filled with cycles, and the life of faith no less so.
    Like your baseball diamond, this quotation from Heraclitus’ “Fragments” always has given a strange kind of comfort:

    “It ever was, and is, and shall be, ever-living fire, in measures being kindled and in measures going out.”

    Wishing you a season blessed with the warmth of re-kindled faith.

  3. Larry C.

    Thank you Padre Steve for your very honest description of your own Dark Night Of The Soul. I hope you keep writing. If you haven’t already, I would highly recommend Frank Schaeffer’s memoir “Crazy for God.”
    Peace, Larry C. (ex-Army Reserve Chaplain).

  4. Pingback: Two Views on Faith at Christmas | Unsettled Christianity

  5. Pingback: Faith and Life: A Meditation for those that Doubt | Padresteve's World…Musings of a Passionate Moderate

  6. Debs

    “I do believe that for many people a religious leader who has doubts and struggles with his or her faith is disconcerting.”

    Not me. Thank you for your honesty. I can’t begin to tell how blessed I was to read your story, and thanking God that I am not the only one who feels like this. I am still a Christian because I cannot stop believing, even though I have no real faith right now. I am still a Christian because I have still have hope.

    Thank you so much for sharing your struggle. May He bless you abundantly and bring you fresh, renewing revelation.

    God bless you

    • padresteve

      Deb
      Thanks for your kind words. I find the journey to be a blessing now.
      Peace and blessings
      Padre Steve+

  7. Jill Archer

    Sometimes I feel I have no one to talk to about this very thing. I endured way more than I thought I should and encountered a sheer hell and pain I never thought possible. I saw evil and suffering as I never had. I searched for God and found no answers and no direction. I started to wonder if what I believed was not possible to help me because it was like believing in the tooth fairy; it makes you feel good but is simply not true. I can not read the bible now as I see it through a new lense that almost feels fictional. The horrible loniless, reslestnessness of spirit sits with me as I imagine myself to be of no significance; my life feels wrought with purposelessness without God. Yet, I try to reach for Him, feel HIm and understand HIm as I once did but I can not feel Him. Still, I fear if I turn my back from HIm that I shall burn in hell. So, I am caught between trying, forcing myself to believe and just trying to live life without thinking about God. I do not understand life anymore or feel comfortable making judgments or decisions. Thanks for your message. Unfortunately, I share it.

    • padresteve

      Jill
      Hang in there, the journey can be lonely and painful. In my struggle I have come to believe that God is a lot more gracious and understanding of our doubts, fears and even unbelief than we give him credit for. While I do not know what trauma has brought you to this place I know that it is probably the most painful ting that you have ever experienced. In my worst times I despaired of life and found it hard to believe that God was anywhere. It was devastating. Know that you are not alone, there are many that have walked similar paths and that God does care for the wounded and broken hearted who struggle with faith and life. I’ll keep you in my prayers as I understand something of your plight. Feel free to look around on this site as you will see the real struggle of one that has been to the abyss. Somehow things are better than they were and faith has returned. Don’t give up.
      Peace
      Steve+

  8. Sherry Bobbins

    Hi Steve.
    I’m a tormented Christian in somewhat of a faith crisis scouring the internet for answers and solace.
    I am not moved by much these days but I felt moved by your honesty in this piece.
    This whole time, I have been reassuring myself that God is big enough to handle my doubts and brutal honesty. I feel freed up by knowing that. But am I big enough to handle this? Right now, I feel like my faith is eroding.

    It’s been slowly eroding since I was in a bible-based cult for a year. Evil, abusive things were done to vulnerable people in the name of God. I now run the international survivors network which I consider to be my ministry, even though only a few of us remain Christians since the experience.

    My Christian community of friends that was once so vibrant has now distintegrated (pre cult that is). A number have fallen away from church, and a few from the faith altogether. My family are non-Christians except for my dad who is not the shining example, but then, who is? And to the rest of my family, I am the joke. I was already a joke before I was Christian, but this really is the icing on the cake for them. I am grateful just to meet someone who is at least neutral on issues of religion because at least I don’t have to deal with their contempt.

    Aaaanyway i don’t mean to sound all “poor me” but just trying to say what has been eroding my faith.

    The church i have been at for the last four years is good in that it is safe and many people there came from another church that became corrupt and abusive. So I find that most of them can relate to my position and have an awareness I don’t find is present in most Christians. But i do find it hard because even though i’m 29 pushing 30, i am by far the youngest person in my church. The second youngest is by husband, aged 36. Then it goes up to the early 40s, with the median age being late 50s. I think part of the issue is that i need some friends my own age or at least in my stage of life. Or maybe i’m just dried up, like maybe even if my church had the features i desired, i would still be dried up.

    I feel “allergic” to hype preachers who illicit emotional responses from people. And allergic to certain parts of the bible ti have seen used as a weapon of fear and control. So i don’t really read the bible anymore, but sometimes read psalms at bed time. I don’t know what my fundamental need is here, except for my Jesus to come and save me. I am really at the end of myself here and to lose my faith after all this would just be too much.

    • padresteve

      Sherry

      I am sorry that you have had to experience this. I can only encourage you not to judge God by some of those who claim to know him better than he knows himself. I have seen so many stories like your own and know some of the heartache of what you are going through. Not only have you had to deal with the situation in the church but the mockery of your family. Please know that I still have some struggles though faith has returned. My faith isn’t the same as when I believed that I had all of the answers. As a fellow wounded Christian I will keep you in my prayers. It is not easy, that I know.

      Peace

      Steve+

  9. Hi,

    Your blog on your crisis of faith really helped me the other night. I shared it on my facebook page. I founded a pregnancy center and was fire and voted off the board. I’ve also had two major surgeries, am estranged from my mother because she married a man who is dangerous to my family and on and on in the past 2 years. Here’s a link to mine if you would like to read it. I’m not having a faith crisis exactly…let’s just call it a “cost of discipleship inventory.” Thanks bud.

    Carrie

  10. auntie-c

    Being in the midst of depression, PTSD and anxiety, not to mention a crisis of faith, thank you. Your thoughts help me remember how much God does love me.

  11. You know I’ve had my problems, as I know of yours. Thank you for putting all this into words. From what I’ve seen, both in your and my experiences, and in talking to a number of people, a faith untested is a faith without depth. I’ve found that people who question, often have a stronger tie to things of this world AND the next, than those who simply “mark time” in their religion and mindset. Well done, as usual.

  12. Laura

    Thank you, it was good to read this today. I found it by googling “How can I admit I am having a crisis of faith?”. I am not a pastor, or person of the church, just a human with a broken heart. Prayer has got so very hard, and I don’t attend church anymore. Church for me doesn’t feel like a safe place. Suddenly it all seems so hard. I also have depression, PTSD, I am a 42 year old breast cancer survivor (Diagnosed in 2014). I am in recovery for drugs and alcohol, with 18 months clean and sober. I struggle with constant suicidal thoughts and ideation, even though I do NOT want to die. I want free of the emotional pain, I want Jesus to make my mind and heart well. Do I feel abandoned by God? No, but after reading the children’s bible to my daughter I was horrified by the old test. stories. I struggle with wondering if the Bible is truly the word of God. How can I believe in that old Test. God? I know he sent himself as Jesus to save the world, but today’s world seems just as barbaric as that in the old testament, with terrible things being committed in His name. I am confused and lonely, and very sad. Your article is a comfort to me. Thank you

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s